10 Civil War History Books That Will Deepen Your Understanding
Recommended by Antonio García Martínez, Ezra Klein, and James McPherson, these Civil War History Books offer expert perspectives on America's defining conflict.
What if the Civil War wasn't just a clash of armies but a complex tapestry of political violence, religious conviction, and leadership struggles? Understanding this conflict demands more than dates and battles; it requires diving deep into the forces that shaped a nation torn apart. Today, Civil War history resonates as a mirror to contemporary struggles over identity, governance, and justice.
Experts like Antonio García Martínez, who highlights the brutal political violence fueling the war, and Ezra Klein, who connects historical tensions to modern political divides, provide invaluable perspectives. Meanwhile, James McPherson, a historian deeply versed in the war’s military and cultural dimensions, guides readers through the nuanced narratives behind the conflict’s enduring legacy.
While these expert-curated books provide proven frameworks, readers seeking content tailored to their specific interests or background might consider creating a personalized Civil War History book that builds on these insights. Tailoring your exploration allows you to focus on leadership, battlefield strategy, political strife, or cultural impacts relevant to your goals.
Best for Confederate military biography enthusiasts
Steven Woodworth, author of Davis and Lee at War, brings authoritative insight into Civil War biographies, making his endorsement particularly meaningful for enthusiasts of Confederate military history. He describes this work as "Outstanding biography, fine battle history, and fascinating reading," highlighting its blend of personal and military narrative. Woodworth's appreciation reflects how the book deepened his understanding of Patrick Cleburne's leadership and battlefield contributions. Alongside him, Albert Castel, author of Decision in the West, praises it as "The finest biography of one of the Confederacy’s finest fighting generals," reinforcing the book's status among Civil War historians.
Craig L. Symonds is Professor Emeritus at the United States Naval Academy where he taught naval history and Civil War History for thirty years. A native of Anaheim, California, Symonds earned his B.A. degree at U.C.L.A., and his Masters and Ph.D. degrees from the University of Florida where he studied under the late John K. Mahon. In the 1970s he was a U.S. Navy officer and the first ensign ever to lecture at the prestigious Naval War College in Newport, Rhode Island. After his naval service, Symonds remained at the War College as a civilian Professor of Strategy from 1974-1975. He came to the Naval Academy in 1976, and during his thirty-year career there he became a very popular professor whose Civil War classes were always over-subscribed. He was named teacher of the Year in 1988, and the Researcher of the Year in 1998, the first person ever to win both awards. He chaired the History Department from 1988 to 1992. In addition to the Meritorious Civilian Service Medal, he was awarded the Civilian Meritorious Service Medal three times. From 1994 to 1995 he served as Professor of Strategy and Policy at the Britannia Naval College in Dartmouth, England. Symonds is the author of twelve books and the editor of nine others. In addition he has written over one hundred scholarly articles in professional journals and popular magazines as well as more than twenty book chapters in historical anthologies. Five of his books were selections of the Book-of-the-Month Club, and six have been selections of the History Book Club. His books have won the Barondess Lincoln Prize, the Daniel and Marilyn Laney Prize, the S.A. Cunningham Award, the Theodore and Franklin D. Roosevelt Prize, and the John Lyman book Prize three times. In 2009 he shared the $50,000 Lincoln Prize with James M. McPherson. He also won the "Annie" Award in Literary Arts given by Anne Arundel County, Maryland. Now retired, Symonds is much in demand around the country as a speaker on Civil War subjects.
When Craig L. Symonds first set out to write this biography, his decades of teaching Civil War history and naval strategy shaped a detailed portrait of Patrick Cleburne's rise as a combat leader and his complex role in the Army of Tennessee. You gain insight into Cleburne's military strategies, his personal politics within the Confederacy, and the dramatic circumstances of his death, with Symonds balancing respect for Cleburne's achievements while dispelling myths. The book includes black-and-white photos and chapters that explore key battles and leadership decisions, making it particularly suited for those interested in military biography or the inner workings of Confederate command. If you're looking for a nuanced understanding of a lesser-known but pivotal figure, this book delivers without unnecessary embellishment.
Antonio García Martínez, author of Chaos Monkeys and former Facebook and Y Combinator insider, highlights the brutal nature of 19th-century American politics, noting "the violence was the lead-up to the Civil War. This book is a great review of just how bloody US congressional politics used to be." His perspective as someone familiar with intense political environments lends weight to his appreciation of Freeman's vivid recounting of congressional clashes. Likewise, Ezra Klein, founder and editor-at-large at Vox Media, praises the book for framing contemporary political violence through a historical lens, sharing how Freeman’s insights continue to influence his thinking about political conflict today.
Author of Chaos Monkeys, former Facebook/Y Combinator
“....on the other hand, the violence was the lead-up to the Civil War. This book is a great review of just how bloody US congressional politics used to be.” (from X)
Joanne B. Freeman, a professor of history and American studies at Yale University, is a leading authority on early national politics and political culture. Author of the award-winning Affairs of Honor: National Politics in the New Republic and editor of The Essential Hamilton and Alexander Hamilton: Writings, she is a cohost of the popular history podcast BackStory. Freeman’s research focuses on political violence and polarization, making her work particularly relevant today.
Civil War History, Political Violence, American Politics, Congressional History, Slavery Debate
Unlike most Civil War history books that focus on battles and military strategies, Joanne B. Freeman delves into the turbulent political atmosphere that fueled the conflict. Drawing from her expertise as a Yale professor specializing in early American political culture, Freeman vividly reconstructs the physical violence erupting in Congress, showing how these clashes over slavery and power escalated national tensions. You’ll find detailed accounts of duels, canings, and brawls, revealing the human drama behind legislative debates, including episodes involving figures like John Quincy Adams and Henry Clay. This book is especially beneficial if you want to understand the political undercurrents and personal animosities that shaped the road to war.
New York Times Notable Book Of The Year
NPR Best Book Of The Year
One Of Smithsonian's Best History Books Of The Year
This AI-tailored book on Civil War campaigns develops a systematic approach with frameworks that adapt to your specific historical interests. The content adjusts based on your chosen focus areas, such as strategy, leadership, or geography, to address the nuanced challenges of analyzing complex military operations. It offers a structured examination of pivotal battles, blending tactical and political insights tailored to your background and goals. Designed to bridge the gap between broad historical narratives and your unique research needs, this book provides focused, actionable perspectives on Civil War military history.
TailoredRead AI creates personalized nonfiction books that adapt to your unique background, goals, and interests. Instead of reading generic content, you get a custom book written specifically for your profession, experience level, and learning objectives. Whether you're a beginner looking for fundamentals or an expert seeking advanced insights, TailoredRead crafts a book that speaks directly to you. Learn more.
2025·50-300 pages·Civil War History, Civil War Campaigns, Military Strategy, Battle Analysis, Leadership Decisions
This tailored book provides an in-depth examination of pivotal military campaigns during the Civil War, focusing on strategic frameworks that shaped battle outcomes. It offers a personalized approach to exploring the tactical decisions, leadership dynamics, and operational contexts of key engagements, adjusting to your specific interests in geography, command structures, or political implications. The methodology emphasizes a tailored framework for dissecting campaign phases, logistics, and battlefield maneuvers, cutting through irrelevant generalizations to fit your precise historical or military focus. Readers gain structured insights into campaign planning, execution, and consequences, situating each battle within broader war efforts and offering comparative analyses to deepen understanding.
Library Journal, a respected authority in history and book reviews, highlights this volume as one of the Best Reference Titles of 2017, emphasizing its collaboration with the Civil War Trust and novelist Jeff Shaara. They praise the book’s combination of essays, detailed maps, and historic photographs, along with suggested hikes through 32 major battlefields. This endorsement reflects how the book enriches understanding of the Civil War by connecting readers not only to the history but to the present-day landscapes, offering a tangible way to experience these historic sites.
“Best Reference Titles of 2017: History. Created in association with the Civil War Trust, the leading organization in Civil War battlefield preservation, and with a foreword by novelist Jeff Shaara, this impressive look at 32 major battlefields contains essays, detailed maps, historic photographs, and suggested hikes (ranging from .2 to 14 miles). Most striking are the images of the battlefields as they look today: beautiful, hallowed landscapes.”
by David T. Gilbert, Jeff Shaara, Civil War Trust··You?
About the Author
David T. Gilbert has written several books about Harpers Ferry and served as editor of the inaugural issue of Hallowed Ground for the Association for the Preservation of Civil War Sites (APCWS)—now merged with the Civil War Trust. His expertise in Civil War history is complemented by his contributions to various historical publications.
Civil War Battlefields: Walking the Trails of History invites you to explore over thirty key Civil War battlefields through a rich blend of vivid photography, detailed maps, and insightful essays. Drawing from David T. Gilbert’s extensive background, including his editorial work for the Association for the Preservation of Civil War Sites, the book unpacks each battlefield’s strategic geography, pivotal moments, and lasting historical impact. You’ll find guidance on how to tour these sites on foot, making it ideal if you want to connect with history physically and intellectually. This book suits anyone fascinated by military history or landscape preservation, especially those planning battlefield visits or seeking a deeper understanding of the Civil War’s terrain and tactics.
James McPherson, a renowned historian of the Civil War and author focused on Jefferson Davis, highlights this book as "The fullest and best history of the Vicksburg campaign." His deep expertise in the complexities of Civil War leadership brings weight to his praise. This book helped him see the campaign not just as a military operation but as a pivotal moment affecting thousands of lives beyond the battlefield. Likewise, David Blight, noted historian and critic, emphasizes how the book brilliantly weaves military and emancipation histories, revealing the full scope of the war’s impact.
Donald L. Miller is the John Henry MacCracken Professor of History Emeritus at Lafayette College and author of ten books, including Vicksburg, and Masters of the Air, currently being made into a television series by Tom Hanks. He has hosted, coproduced, or served as historical consultant for more than thirty television documentaries and has written for The New York Times, The Washington Post, and other publications.
What if everything you knew about the Vicksburg campaign was wrong? Donald L. Miller challenges traditional military histories by integrating the social upheaval surrounding the siege, notably how tens of thousands of enslaved people sought freedom and reshaped the region’s economy. You learn not just battlefield strategies but also the profound societal transformations that accompanied Grant’s campaign. The book offers detailed narratives of military maneuvers alongside the experiences of freed slaves and their impact on the Confederacy’s collapse. If you want to grasp the full significance of the campaign beyond tactics, this book gives you that broader, nuanced understanding.
Civil War Round Table of New York’s Fletcher Pratt Literary Award
Austin Civil War Round Table’s Daniel M. & Marilyn W. Laney Book Prize
Army Historical Foundation Distinguished Writing Award
James McPherson, a leading Civil War historian and author, highlights the Bible's omnipresence in the conflict, noting that scripture guided soldiers and civilians alike through unprecedented sacrifice. He recalls how the pervasive religious rhetoric reframed his understanding of the war's moral complexity: 'War is everywhere in the New Testament, as in the Old,' declared a Southern clergyman in 1863. Byrd's work deepened McPherson's appreciation for how faith sustained both sides amid devastation. Complementing this view, Harry Stout from Yale University praises Byrd's meticulous analysis of scriptural references, underscoring the nuanced religious landscape that shaped the war and echoed Lincoln's assertion about shared scripture despite bitter division.
“'War is everywhere in the New Testament, as in the Old,' declared a Southern clergyman in 1863. The Bible was the most frequently cited book in both North and South during the Civil War. It served as a guide to explain the sacrifices and sufferings of soldiers and civilians. James Byrd's magisterial study helps the modern reader appreciate the all-encompassing role of scripture in America's most deadly experience.”
James P. Byrd is Chair of the Graduate Department Religion and Associate Professor of American Religious History at Vanderbilt University Divinity School. He earned his master's degree at Duke University and his Ph.D. at Vanderbilt University. He is the author of Sacred Scripture, Sacred War: The Bible and the American Revolution (OUP, 2013). His research interests center on religion, violence, and the Bible in American history.
Unlike most Civil War history books that focus strictly on military or political narratives, James P. Byrd explores the profound influence of the Bible on the conflict’s cultural and ideological dimensions. Drawing from his expertise as Chair of Religion at Vanderbilt University, Byrd reveals how scripture shaped justifications for war, framed moral debates on slavery and secession, and provided solace amid unprecedented carnage. You’ll gain insight into specific biblical passages cited by both Union and Confederate sides and understand how faith intertwined with politics and identity during America’s deadliest war. This book suits anyone interested in the intersection of religion and history, especially how sacred texts inform national trauma and conflict.
This AI-tailored book on religious ideology during the Civil War develops a systematic approach with frameworks that adapt to your specific interests in faith and politics. The content is created after you specify your focus areas, such as scriptural interpretation or political rhetoric, addressing the nuanced role religion played in shaping civil war ideologies and cultural tensions. It bridges historical insights with personalized analysis, providing depth beyond conventional overviews.
TailoredRead AI creates personalized nonfiction books that adapt to your unique background, goals, and interests. Instead of reading generic content, you get a custom book written specifically for your profession, experience level, and learning objectives. Whether you're a beginner looking for fundamentals or an expert seeking advanced insights, TailoredRead crafts a book that speaks directly to you. Learn more.
2025·50-300 pages·Civil War History, Civil War Religion, Political Ideology, Biblical Influence, Religious Rhetoric
This personalized exploration provides a nuanced framework for understanding how religious beliefs shaped political ideologies and cultural dynamics during the Civil War era. It offers an analytical approach to interpreting biblical references and religious rhetoric employed by key figures and factions, ensuring the content fits your particular focus areas such as theological influence on policy or grassroots faith movements. The tailored approach cuts through generic historical narratives to examine the intersection of scripture and ideology, addressing the complexities of faith-driven motivations and their impact on the conflict’s progression and public sentiment.
Lawrence Wright, author of The Looming Tower, brings a distinctive voice to Civil War history, making his endorsement especially meaningful for those fascinated by America’s defining conflict. After exploring this book during his extensive research, he remarked, "This brilliantly told account of the final year of the Civil War brings to life the vivid personalities who struggled for control of America’s destiny." His appreciation highlights how S.C. Gwynne's narrative blends sweeping historical events with intimate character studies, reshaping how you may view the war's final phase. Additionally, Hampton Sides praises Gwynne's fresh perspective, noting how the book compresses a complex saga into a powerful, almost tragic narrative that redefines familiar history.
Author of The Looming Tower: Al-Qaeda and the Road to 9/11
“This brilliantly told account of the final year of the Civil War brings to life the vivid personalities who struggled for control of America’s destiny. At once sweeping and intimate, Hymns of the Republic is a masterwork of history.”
S.C. Gwynne is the author of His Majesty’s Airship, Hymns of the Republic, and the New York Times bestsellers Rebel Yell and Empire of the Summer Moon, which was a finalist for the Pulitzer Prize and the National Book Critics Circle Award. He spent most of his career as a journalist, including stints with Time as bureau chief, national correspondent, and senior editor, and with Texas Monthly as executive editor. He lives in Austin, Texas, with his wife.
When S.C. Gwynne discovered the complexity and human drama of the Civil War's final year, he crafted a narrative that challenges familiar perceptions of iconic figures like Robert E. Lee, Ulysses S. Grant, and Clara Barton. You learn how the war’s last year was shaped not only by battles but by political struggles, the introduction of black soldiers, and the evolving nature of warfare and medicine. For anyone fascinated by American history or military strategy, this book offers detailed insights into leadership failures and triumphs, the impact of guerrilla warfare, and pivotal moments such as Lincoln's contested reelection and Lee’s surrender. Gwynne’s work suits readers seeking a nuanced, character-driven understanding of the Civil War's closing chapter.
Jeffry Wert, author of 'A Glorious Army: Robert E. Lee's Triumph, 1862-1863,' brings a deep understanding of Civil War military leadership to his recommendation of this book. He highlights how the partnership between Lee and Jackson reshaped the Eastern Theater of the Civil War during a critical year, providing fresh insight into their strategic collaboration. Wert’s reflection reveals how this analysis changed his perspective on Confederate command. Likewise, Gary Gallagher, known for his work on Lee's army, underscores Keller’s reminder of how vital command relationships were in shaping the war’s outcome, reinforcing the book's value for those studying Civil War leadership.
Author of 'A Glorious Army: Robert E. Lee's Triumph, 1862-1863'
“The partnership of Robert E. Lee and Stonewall Jackson reshaped the course of the Civil War in the East in a span of roughly a year from the spring of 1862 to the latter's death in May 1863.”
Christian B. Keller is the Dwight D. Eisenhower Chair of National Security and Professor of History in the Department of National Security and Strategy at the United States Army War College in Carlisle, Pennsylvania. Keller is the author of five previous histories for academic presses. This is his first trade book.
Dwight D. Eisenhower Chair of National Security Christian B. Keller draws from his extensive military history expertise to explore the strategic partnership between Robert E. Lee and Stonewall Jackson. You’ll gain a nuanced understanding of how their friendship, leadership styles, and faith intertwined to shape Confederate strategies during critical moments of the Civil War. Keller challenges traditional views by highlighting their combined influence on battles and decision-making, particularly from 1862 to 1863. If you’re intrigued by Civil War leadership dynamics or Confederate command structures, this book offers insightful analysis, though those seeking broader military history might find its focus quite specialized.
Jody Williams, Nobel Peace Prize Laureate and Chair of the Nobel Women’s Initiative, values this book for its thorough treatment of a weapon she has campaigned against globally. After witnessing the devastating human toll of landmines worldwide, she found in "America’s Buried History" a crucial exploration of their origins during the Civil War. She describes it as an absorbing eye-opening history that deepened her understanding of landmines' political and military contexts, shedding light on how these devices transitioned from controversial innovations to a widespread scourge.
Nobel Peace Prize Laureate and Nobel Women’s Initiative Chair
“America’s Buried History is a compelling and exhaustive exploration of a deadly weapon—the anti-personal landmine—introduced for the first time on a broad scale in the American Civil War. Landmines would eventually cost the lives and limbs of hundreds of thousands of people around the world, which ultimately resulted in the prohibition by most countries. This book is an absorbing eye-opening history that combines insightful political decisions, military history, technical details, and biographies.”
Kenneth R. Rutherford is known for his decades of work in the landmine discipline. He is cofounder of the Landmine Survivors Network and a prominent leader in the International Campaign to Ban Landmines, which won the 1997 Nobel Peace Prize. A professor of political science at James Madison University, he directed the university’s Center for International Stabilization and Recovery for ten years, which for more than 21 years has been recognized as a global leader in international efforts to combat the effects of landmines and explosive remnants of war. He holds a Ph.D. in Government from Georgetown University, and B.A. and MBA degrees from the University of Colorado, where he lettered in football as a walk-on noseguard and inducted into its Hall for Distinguished alumni.
When Kenneth R. Rutherford first revealed the overlooked role of landmines in the American Civil War, he challenged the traditional narratives that often omit this deadly weapon’s impact. Drawing from his extensive expertise in landmine advocacy and political science, Rutherford meticulously unpacks how these “infernal devices” shaped battles and ethical debates within the Confederacy. You’ll gain detailed insights into the types of mines used, their deployment across multiple states, and the lasting controversies surrounding their use. This book is best suited for those intrigued by military technology’s darker side and the ethical dilemmas of warfare, offering a focused look beyond typical Civil War histories.
James McPherson, author of 'Embattled Rebel,' brings unparalleled insight into Civil War history, making his recommendation especially meaningful. After engaging deeply with the book during his research, he called it "a genuinely fresh set of insights about the Civil War. Murray and Hsieh have crafted a military narrative that goes well beyond anything else in the literature." His appreciation stems from how the book reshaped his understanding of the war's complexities, from leadership dynamics to battlefield culture. Likewise, Lawrence Freedman, emeritus professor at King's College London, highlights the book’s thorough exploration of strategic decisions, logistics, and intelligence, reinforcing its value for anyone serious about Civil War military history.
“A genuinely fresh set of insights about the Civil War. Murray and Hsieh have crafted a military narrative that goes well beyond anything else in the literature.”
Williamson Murray is a prominent military historian known for his extensive research and writings on military history, particularly the Civil War. He has authored and edited numerous books and articles, contributing significantly to the understanding of military strategy and history.
When Williamson Murray and Wayne Wei-siang Hsieh revisited the Civil War, they challenged the usual narratives by highlighting its transformation into modern warfare shaped by industrial and revolutionary forces. You’ll gain a nuanced understanding of how leadership, logistics, and army cultures influenced the conflict’s outcome, with detailed portraits of figures like Lincoln and Grant. The book moves beyond battles to examine how technology, chance, and strategy combined on a continental scale. This depth makes it ideal if you want insights into military evolution rather than just a chronological account.
Glenn Kirschner, a legal analyst and former federal prosecutor, highlights the value of this book for understanding leadership in complex political environments. His remark that “Not immune to advice” is a beautiful thing underscores how Lincoln’s team of rivals approach led to the most informed decisions during the Civil War. Kirschner appreciates how this detailed account reshaped his view of presidential leadership amid conflict. Also, Adam Townsend offers a contrasting perspective, calling it a thoroughly enjoyable yet revisionist history, inviting readers to engage critically with the narrative.
““Not immune to advice” is a beautiful thing. In fact, a team of rivals produces the best, most informed decisions, IMO. It’s also one heck of a book - Team of Rivals - by Doris Kearns Goodwin” (from X)
Doris Kearns Goodwin’s work for President Johnson inspired her career as a presidential historian. Her first book was Lyndon Johnson and the American Dream. She followed up with the Pulitzer Prize–winning No Ordinary Time: Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt: The Homefront in World War II. She earned the Lincoln Prize for Team of Rivals, in part the basis for Steven Spielberg’s film Lincoln, and the Carnegie Medal for The Bully Pulpit, about the friendship between Theodore Roosevelt and William Howard Taft. Her bestselling Leadership: In Turbulent Times was the inspiration for the History Channel docuseries on Abraham Lincoln, Theodore Roosevelt, and Franklin Roosevelt, which she executive produced. Her most recent book, An Unfinished Love Story: A Personal History of the 1960s, provides a front-row seat to the pivotal people—JFK, LBJ, RFK, and MLK—and events of this momentous decade.
When Doris Kearns Goodwin first explored the complex relationships within Abraham Lincoln's cabinet, she uncovered a leadership style rooted in empathy and strategic collaboration. This book reveals how Lincoln's ability to understand and unite his political rivals was crucial to preserving the Union during the Civil War. You'll gain insights into managing divergent personalities and navigating political conflict, with detailed accounts of key figures like Seward and Chase and their interactions with Lincoln. If you want to deepen your grasp of leadership under pressure and the human side of presidential decision-making, this book offers a richly detailed narrative that goes beyond typical political biographies.
Stop following generic advice—get targeted Civil War strategies that fit your interests without reading 10+ books.
Focused historical insights
•Customized learning paths
•Efficient knowledge building
Join 15,000+ Civil War History enthusiasts who've personalized their approach
Campaigns Uncovered
Faith and Conflict
Political Violence Roots
Leadership in Crisis
Conclusion
This collection of 10 books weaves together themes of leadership, battlefield strategy, political upheaval, and cultural forces that defined the Civil War era. They reveal how individuals like Patrick Cleburne and Abraham Lincoln shaped the conflict’s course, how political violence and religious beliefs intensified divisions, and how technology and terrain influenced outcomes.
If you’re grappling with understanding the war’s military dynamics, starting with A Savage War alongside Stonewall of the West will ground you in strategy and leadership. For those more intrigued by political and cultural complexity, The Field of Blood and A Holy Baptism of Fire and Blood offer deep dives into the ideological currents.
Once you've absorbed these expert insights, create a personalized Civil War History book to bridge the gap between general principles and your specific situation. Whether you're a student, educator, or history enthusiast, tailored content can sharpen your focus and enrich your understanding.
Frequently Asked Questions
I'm overwhelmed by choice – which book should I start with?
Start with A Savage War for a broad military overview or The Field of Blood to understand the political conflicts that led to war. Both provide solid foundations to build your knowledge.
Are these books too advanced for someone new to Civil War History?
Not at all. These books balance detailed scholarship with accessible storytelling, making them suitable for newcomers and seasoned readers alike.
What's the best order to read these books?
Begin with broader narratives like Team of Rivals and A Savage War, then delve into specialized topics such as leadership in Stonewall of the West or religious influence in A Holy Baptism of Fire and Blood.
Do I really need to read all of these, or can I just pick one?
You can pick based on your interest—military, political, or cultural history. Each book offers distinct insights, so choose what aligns with your curiosity or needs.
Are any of these books outdated given how fast Civil War History changes?
These books reflect current scholarship with fresh perspectives, including recent social and cultural analyses, ensuring relevance to contemporary understanding.
Can I get personalized insights tailored to my specific interests in Civil War History?
Yes! While these expert books provide excellent foundations, you can create a personalized Civil War History book tailored to your unique goals and background for focused learning.
📚 Love this book list?
Help fellow book lovers discover great books, share this curated list with others!
